Sarah Michelle Gellar and Jennifer Love Hewitt: No Feud, Just Red Carpet Chaos

Fans of the 1997 slasher classic “I Know What You Did Last Summer” were abuzz earlier this week following the premiere of the new film in the franchise. Despite both Sarah Michelle Gellar and Jennifer Love Hewitt attending the event, there were no shared photos of the two on the red carpet, prompting widespread online speculation about a possible falling out between the iconic stars .

The conversations were fueled by Gellar’s Instagram post summarizing her excitement for the event, which included photos with other cast members but none with Hewitt. Commenters on the post quickly jumped to conclusions, with some suggesting, “the beef is real,” and others dissecting every digital interaction for signs of tension .

Addressing the speculation head-on, Sarah Michelle Gellar took to Instagram to clarify the situation. “For everyone asking—I never got to see @jenniferlovehewitt who is fantastic in the movie. I was inside with my kids when the big carpet happened. And unfortunately JLH didn't come to the after party. If you have ever been to one of these it's crazy. I sadly didn't get pics with most of the cast. But that doesn't change how amazing I think they all are. Unfortunately some things happen only in real life and not online,” Gellar wrote, putting a definitive end to the feud narrative .

Jennifer Love Hewitt, too, has expressed nothing but admiration for her former co-star in previous interviews, and neither party has provided any verifiable evidence of tension or animosity . The entire situation underscores how quickly narratives can be constructed—and dismantled—by a combination of social media speculation and the absence of photographic “proof.”

This episode highlights a broader issue relevant to LGBTQ+ communities and allies: the ways in which public narratives and relationships—platonic, romantic, or otherwise—are scrutinized and interpreted through online engagement. The absence of a shared photo, or a brief comment, can rapidly snowball into a perceived feud, demonstrating how digital culture often conflates visibility with validation .

For LGBTQ+ individuals, whose relationships and identities are frequently misinterpreted or erased in mainstream spaces, this incident offers a microcosm of a larger phenomenon: identity and interpersonal dynamics are too often defined by external observers rather than by the individuals themselves. The swift response from both Gellar and Hewitt serves as a reminder that real connections—whether friendships, chosen family, or romantic partnerships—are not always accurately reflected online, and that speculation can quickly overshadow genuine allyship and support .

Ultimately, the rumored feud between Sarah Michelle Gellar and Jennifer Love Hewitt has been thoroughly debunked by the actors themselves. Instead, their handling of the situation demonstrates the importance of direct communication and the dangers of conflating social media engagement with real-world relationships .