Colton Underwood to Co-Host Queer Inclusive Dating Show ‘Are You My First?’ on Hulu

Colton Underwood, the former “Bachelor” star who made headlines after coming out as gay, is stepping back into the spotlight as the co-host of Hulu’s upcoming reality series, “Are You My First?” The show, set to premiere on August 18, 2025, will feature Underwood alongside fellow reality TV alum Kaitlyn Bristowe, offering a fresh take on the dating genre by bringing together the “largest, hottest group of virgins ever assembled” in search of romance and self-discovery .

“Are You My First?” aims to break new ground by focusing on the unique experiences of virgins—people who have not yet had sexual intercourse—giving them a safe, judgment-free space to explore intimacy. The series sets its cast in a tropical paradise designed specifically for open and honest conversations about love, relationships, and first-time experiences. The show’s official synopsis describes it as a “groundbreaking new dating experiment” where participants are empowered to form connections and navigate romantic possibilities, while tackling challenges that test their compatibility and emotional readiness .

While early promotional materials for “Are You My First?” emphasize its appeal to a broad audience, Underwood’s involvement as an openly gay host and LGBTQ+ advocate signals that the casting and storytelling will be inclusive of all identities. This represents a notable shift for mainstream dating shows, which have historically centered heterosexual narratives. Underwood, who became the first openly gay lead in “The Bachelor” franchise and subsequently starred in a documentary about his coming-out journey, brings personal experience and authenticity to his new role .

The announcement of “Are You My First?” has been welcomed by LGBTQ+ advocates and entertainment critics, who see the series as an opportunity to increase representation of LGBTQ+ individuals and relationships in reality television. Underwood’s journey from a reality TV contestant to an outspoken member of the LGBTQ+ community has inspired many viewers, especially those who have struggled with their own identities in the face of public scrutiny .

By featuring a cast with diverse backgrounds and orientations, the show seeks to normalize conversations about sexuality, intimacy, and waiting for the “right” moment, regardless of sexual identity. For many LGBTQ+ singles, discussions around virginity and first experiences can be complicated by societal expectations and lack of representation in mainstream media. “Are You My First?” aims to challenge those norms by offering a supportive environment where all participants are encouraged to share their stories and pursue authentic connections .

Produced by the teams behind “Queer Eye” and “Love Island,” “Are You My First?” is part of a broader movement to make reality TV more inclusive and reflective of modern society . As media companies recognize the value of authentic LGBTQ+ storytelling, shows like this play a crucial role in expanding public perceptions of love and relationships.

With its unique format and affirming messaging, “Are You My First?” is poised to become a landmark series for both LGBTQ+ audiences and reality TV fans at large. As Colton Underwood and Kaitlyn Bristowe prepare to guide contestants through transformative journeys, viewers can anticipate a season filled with heartfelt moments, genuine connections, and groundbreaking visibility for all identities.